Contribution to a poster project of the the Kyiv Perennial (the 2023/2024 edition of the Kyiv Biennial)
A Spade is just a Weaponised Heart
Summary
Information
Documentation
Notes
Versions
A spade is just a weaponised heart
Reflecting on the given question (“What will happen to Europe if the war against Ukraine continues for ten more years?”), and the importance of the number 10 within this question, we were reminded of the way graphic elements are usually positioned on playing cards. In particular, we had to think of the Ten of Spades, and the meaning of this specific card within tarot and cartomancy circles.
There are different (sometimes conflicting) possible readings – but generally, the Ten of Spades seems to indicate bad news. Casually browsing through weblogs dedicated to the occult art of cartomancy, we came across several negative interpretations of this specific card (“Traditionally, a card of misfortune, grief, ruin, and tragic endings”, “The Ten of Spades announces a sad event – in cartomancy, this card is quite negative as it brings sorrow, sadness and pain”, “Ten of Spades: unfortunate news”, etc.).
A reason for these negative associations might be found in the origins of the symbol. The motif of the spade is generally associated with weapons, and the military. The spade is often seen as a stylised sword, or spearhead. And of course, a spade is an upside-down heart – in fact, it is a weaponised heart.
We’re not superstitious people, and don’t believe in tarot or cartomancy (or horoscopes or God or ourselves, for that matter) – but we do recognise the graphic power of a playing card, and the way it works as an urgent image. And we certainly realised that the negative meaning of the Ten of Spades perfectly echoed the pessimism of the original question that was posed to us. That’s why we thought that the simple act, of pulling the Ten of Spades from our deck (or rather, from our sleeves), would be a fitting reaction to the question at hand.
Within the context of our poster, the Ten of Spades then represents the horrific notion of ten years of future war. Or the ten years of past war, since the Maidan revolution. Or we can see the spades as representing the European countries that are about to fall. Or ten targets. Or a graveyard of crosses. Or a field of weapons. In a way, all these associations are valid.
However, after contemplating the motif of the spades, we also felt the need (or better said, urge) to somehow negate this dark pessimism – and to somehow try to turn the symbolism around.
That’s why, right before we handed in our poster, we decided to literally ‘cross out’ the ten spades – as a way to destabilise or neutralise its original (negative) meaning. Of course, this ‘crossing out’ is more a symbolic, cathartic act – but still, we feel we had to do it. In that sense, the poster represents a “negation of the negation” of sorts – it’s a negative symbol, being negated by being crossed out.
After we contributed the poster, we discussed the piece with Vasyl Cherepanyn (head of the Visual Culture Research Center in Kyiv, organizer of both the Kyiv Biennial and Kyiv Perennial, and overall brilliant thinker) – and he offered some meaningful insights as well. As Vasyl generously pointed out, “the poster hits the very heart of the spade/spearhead – which is the most precise depiction of the death drive of war – as the heart is obviously a (visual) root of the spearhead, and it is that obscene surplus that turns the heart into the spearhead”. As Vasyl further noted (and we quote from his e-mail from January 25, 2024):
The card as an (unfortunate) fate – it's a constant horrible reality in the trenches – and that's a main topicality of the whole Greek tragedy legacy. At the same time, this way of representation actually refers to the type of depiction that the military uses to mark the number of eliminated enemy targets. […] Also, the Ukrainian military very often uses 'crossing out' when publishing the photos/infos of the killed occupants, especially significant or high-ranked ones. […] And spearheads on the cards look of course very much like explosions caused by the shelling/bombardments, so crossing them out is basically the most fundamental and urgent demand/claim/position required today more than ever.
–
And that’s the full story behind the poster. It’s a graphic composition that tries to reveal how spades are just weaponised hearts – and a cathartic (and perhaps foolish) attempt to somehow negate the negative. In that sense, it’s also a plea to “beat the spades, with a red heart” (to indirectly refer to the famous poster by El Lissitzky).
Experimental Jetset
Amsterdam
July 19, 2024